|
Genre: short comics with the themes of Horror and
Love
This
review may come across as a little strange as it
does not actually cover any of the comics featured
in Cold Sweat & Tears. This is because, instead
of being an anthology of new work, Cold Sweat &
Tears is a compiled collection from 2 previous anthologies:
'Love, Sweat & Tears' and 'Cold Sweat'.
Therefore rather than focus on the stories in the
volume, I will be looking at the differences between
this and the originals and if (like me) you already
own the originals, the pros and cons of buying this
book in addition.
The
actual comics will be covered in a future review
of the original anthologies (I'd better do that
one next hadn't I? ^_~ ) and then probably merged
with this one in some way.
A
Little Bit of History
'Love,
Sweat & Tears' and 'Cold Sweat' were Sweatdrop
Studios' first and second anthologies. They were
both released in a simple stapled format, so it
seems to make sense to bind them together as a collected
book for future sales.
Saying
that, if you are interested in what the authors
are producing right now then this is not the book
for you. This is a good buy for anyone who is interested
in UK manga in general (especially UK manga history),
beginners who are interested in seeing what some
of the Sweatdrop members were producing when they
were first starting out, or for those who are following
the work of one or more of the artists in question.
Additions
to the Original Comics
Introduction
(by Dock): this explains where the book came
from and why it has been produced.
The
History: some freshly written information about
the original anthologies, along with a reproduction
of the original introductions by Keds.
About
Us Section: there is about a paragraph of information
on each author, positioned towards the end of the
book (akin to the notes on the authors in a Tokyopop
Rising Stars of Manga anthology). This covers the
achievements of each author since the original anthologies
were printed and makes for an interesting read.
Illustrations:
new black and white illustrations of some of the
characters in the short stories, produced by the
authors specifially for this volume.
- 2 new illustrations by Emma Vieceli, based on
'Love Senseless' and 'The Politics of Tears'
- 2 new illustrations by Dock, based on 'Out of
Reach'
- 1 new illustration by Laura Watton based on 'Black
Peace'
Comic
Strips: 10 strips from 'Rabid Monkeys' are printed
towards the back of the book - this was webcomic
(by Fehed and Shari) that ran from 2002-2004 but
has now ended. One strip from it had appeared at
the front of each of the previous antholgies.
Trivia:
there are 2 pages of trivia at the end of the book
covering the production of the original anthologies.
They range from stories of printing mishaps to some
of the cameos and references present in some of
the comics.
Ads:
a few pages of ads for books the artists are now
appearing in.
Conclusions
If
you have never seen the 2 original anthologies that
this book was compiled from and you are at all interested
in UK manga, then you will probably find this an
interesting (and possibly even essential) addition
to your manga collection.
However,
if you aleady own the originals and are not someone
who is very into extra content you are not going
to find any new comics here.
So,
throwing scepticism about buying a volume full of
comics I already own aside, the extra content is
what needs to be examined. Luckily it seems to have
some thought put into it, and on the whole lends
more depth to the experience of re-reading the comics.
Should I want to re-experience these short stories
again, I would most likely pick up this book from
my shelf rather than the originals, as it is a neat
microcosm of comics and extras.
Note:
'Biomecha: Thought' by Laura Watton, which originally
appeared in 'Love, Sweat & Tears' has been removed
from the lineup for this re-print, however it is
still in print and now appears in Biomecha volume
1.
Lineup
of Comics Featured in 'Cold Sweat & Tears'
'Love
Senseless' by Emma Vieceli
'Simple
Love' by Hwei Lim (no longer a Sweatdrop member)
'Out
of Reach' by Dock
'A
Message to You' by Keds
'Faded
and Torn' by Fehed Said and Keds
'Black
Peace' by Laura Watton
'Eine
Kliene' by Selina Dean
'Caveboy
Bink' by Monkey-X (no longer a Sweatdrop member)
'The
Politics of Tears' by Fehed Said and Emma Vieceli
'Bunny'
by Selina Dean
|